The Sindh High Court has allowed 110 constitutional petitions challenging the levy of Additional Customs Duty (ACD) on imports by automotive manufacturers and Green Field Investors. The petitions, filed during 2019–2021, questioned the imposition of ACD under Section 18(5) of the Customs Act, 1969, through various Statutory Regulatory Orders (SROs). The dispute principally concerned imported components, sub-assemblies and raw materials used in manufacturing vehicles and automotive parts, where the petitioners claimed protection under the applicable concessionary framework.
The Court examined the protection available under SRO 484(I)/2016 and subsequent notifications. In the case of Green Field Investors, the Court held that the relevant proviso, read with SRO 837(I)/2021, excluded the petitioners from further ACD for the specified period. Regarding existing manufacturers, the Court observed that the applicable ACD rate had been capped for five years under the relevant framework. Consequently, the additional levy imposed through the challenged notifications was declared unlawful insofar as it applied to the petitioners.
Importantly, the Court also restrained customs authorities from recovering the disputed ACD and directed the return of securities furnished by the petitioners to secure the levy. The decision highlights the significance of statutory concessions and the limits of subsequent notifications where existing protections apply. Automotive manufacturers and eligible investors should carefully examine the judgment, their applicable concessionary arrangements and any outstanding ACD disputes to determine whether the ruling provides grounds for relief in their particular circumstances.